文章若未特別註明,皆採用 知识共享许可协议 請自覺遵守





Against EU Copyright Directive Article 13

人云E云 posted @ 2018年7月04日 22:17 in 信息技術 with tags 互聯網 己見 , 489 阅读


While reading wikipedia these days, there is a new banner calling for against the new "Directive on Copyright in the Digital Single Market" (which will be voted on 5 July) / "EU Copyright directive" / "file 2016/0280(COD)".

The three buttons link to the following pages respectively:

A brief reading shows that many organizations/foundations (e.g. EFF, Creative Commons, Wikimedia Foundation) oppose to this directive.

The context of this directive can be found at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:52016PC0593

The main against of this directive is Article 11 and Article 13, especially Article 13.

My words

I should say I agree with many of the disputes that Article 13 should be reformed before applied (explanation at the end). One most probable consequence is that MEMEs will become unavailable. (And this will be one more of the stupid things people have done in recent years, just to satisfy the stale copyright laws.)

I don't know what really works, but I found three sites describing some ways:


The texts in the given link differs some bit between what's described in that wikipedia article. I presume this because of the different versions of the document.

Article 13 grants the censoring and blocking ability and obligation to "Information society service providers" (mostly social networking websites, including both commercial ones, e.g. twitter, facebook, and non-commercial ones, e.g. GNUSocial instances, if I understand correctly). This ability suggests them to use "effective content recognition technologies" to "prevent the availability on their services of works or other subject-matter identified by rightholders (through the cooperation with the service providers)".

Although this ability and obligation is supposed to be "appropriate and proportionate", but at least I don't believe commercial bodies (i.e. companies) will do this "appropriately" in a minimal effort way. They will overactive, both for their "compliance with the law" and for their profit purpose. Some companies in China have already demonstrated this, and I guess there are also some examples in Europe and America.

The piece of text says "identified by rightholders", but in reality "rightholders" in many cases are not a single human but a company. We have heard many stories how companies over-use their copyright to prevent what we as humans see as normal behaviours (let alone I don't totally agree with the copyright [law] nowadays because I think they are developed for paper-publishing era not digital era).

The "Information society service providers" are, most of the time, companies; companies are for profit. Therefore, the nature of capital makes them not sympathetic, and blocking the Internet doesn't really affect their profit (because "everyone" does this, leaving us no choice). https://twitter.com/EvenDragsnes/status/1014394747706925056 is definitely not a future I want.

(Terrorism and some other things shall be dealt with, but this directive has nothing to do with that.)

cleaning services in 说:
2019年9月29日 11:44

Truck's window cleaning is absolutely not necessarily a quick job, and it is a fact that virtually all cleaning assistance do typically the window cleaning on an inefficient process which leaves a considerable amount of stains not to mention dust which may be visible at closer examination. This might be something that anyone can avoid any time you call typically the services from Spectrum cleaning who ? re the preferred window cleaning companies, for we obtain a widows which means clean for which you forget construct y were there at all until most people bump engrossed. Yes, we've been that experienced!

star lite shopping m 说:
2019年11月18日 08:52

Make your home look a lot more spacious by removing any needless junk (hire space for storing when you have to). You'll see a positive change in just how your closet look, plus your garage, deck and toilet. Buyers desire to feel just like they're acquiring sufficient area,

uk cleaning director 说:
2020年3月28日 10:44

Anybody can see the comfort from a clean not to mention well held on to home. Home cleaning can be described as necessity a lot of people are unable to keep their residence cleans due to their fast paced schedules. Homes could be cleaned regularly as a way for unpleasant odors and vermin infestations to always be prevented.

mentholatum home 说:
2020年3月28日 10:45

Nearly everybody define high-end majorly in relation to price but you will find so much more to luxury than how much cash you pay. It is really hard towards define high-end homes on an exact process because this really something characterized by several causes.

I sell pittsburgh ho 说:
2020年3月28日 10:46

For everybody who is buying home that was previously inspected then you need to have your have inspection done to always be protected for the reason that fully as they can be. If anyone speak to you that it can be fine to employ the recent home examination report they've been wrong. Your are not preserved well in the slightest. When Habitation Investigating does home inspection the litigant has the ability to get a particular 18 few weeks warranty for ones fee from 12 a long time.

wanamassa reale stat 说:
2020年3月28日 10:46

So you must be to be successful real estate investor? Most certainly, you prefer your goal setting tips in lines. In order accomplish the greatest possibility that you'll achieving a goals you must be setting GREAT goals. Nowadays, not typically the Webster standard of great, but as an alternative SMART for being an acronym for the purpose of Specific, Measurable, Conceivable, Realistic, not to mention Timely.

north bama real esta 说:
2020年3月28日 10:47

Realty is typically the legal duration encompassing acquire with something belonging to the acquire like architecture, particularly building. These are actually immobile and / or fixed buildings. It will be common jargon made use of in several jurisdictions along the lines of Australia, Europe, United Kingdom and our great country.

maids in dubai 说:
2020年5月01日 12:11

We humans like to celebrate all seasonal festivals together with our near and dear ones. Halloween is one such great occasion that enables everyone to spend their time with their friends and family. Halloween is an antique festival that has adopted a modern day spirit. We still commemorate the dead ones but in our own special ways. Trick or Treat is a modern day invention.

painters in Dubai 说:
2020年5月01日 12:11

It's important to note that some of the CertaPro Painters complaints on the internet contain consumer reviews from angry customers or previous franchise owners that put off customers buying a professional painting company. These reviews claim that CertaPro has cheated previous franchise owners and customers,

maids in dubai 说:
2021年6月07日 11:54

A family house contains numerous hidden parts, and almost all of the household owners tend not to pay much care about these parts. Because cleanup these parts requires specific equipment and tools. So, contact your professional home cleaning team and familiarize yourself with about the instruments and start off cleaning these kind of hidden corners to any extent further.

PUC Blueprint 2023 说:
2022年8月25日 15:48

Karnataka II PUC Syllabus 2023, Blue Print II PUC Syllabus 2023, Name of the organization Karnataka Department of Pre University Education Name of Exam I & II PUC Examination 2023, Name of the Subject Languages, Commerce, PUC Blueprint 2023 Science, Question Paper Download Kar PUC Syllabus & Blue Print 2023, Pdf Format Download PUC Examination Conducted Month of March 2023,-2023,, More Info Official Website www.pue.kar.nic.in

BSNL Wifi Plans Unli 说:
2023年2月07日 08:25

ISP provides unlimited calls to any network round the clock in all the BSNL broadband plans over fiber and DSL networks, and Here we update the latest BSNL broadband unlimited plans daily across India as and when the update released for home and business tariff, BSNL Wifi Plans Unlimited for Home So check each plan in detail to opt for best tariff. BSNL broadband plans over DSL and Bharat Fiber (FTTH) technologies are available, we categorize each plan and provide the updated information of all the circles with new plans and tariff.

CBSE 9th Question P 说:
2023年7月10日 16:12

Students Can Check These CBSE 9th Question Paper 2024 All Subjects are Upload by According to the Changed Exam Pattern CBSE 9th Final Examination 2024, Students With the help of CBSE 9th Question Paper 2024 Students CBSE 9th Question Paper 2024 may Understand the Pdf Format and type of Blueprint to be asked in Final Exam and they can also know the design of CBSE Important Question Paper 2024 according to which they can Formulate an Effective plan for their 9th Class Exam Preparations All Subjects English, Hindi, Science, Social Science, Maths, With the help of These CBSE 9th Solved Questions Paper 2024.

登录 *

loading captcha image...
or Ctrl+Enter